There are some basic criteria for administrative promotions:
Practically everyone is at least satisfactory. However, a promotion isn't entirely automatic in case someone unworthy slips through the hiring process:In order to be promoted administratively, career and career candidate members of the Foreign Service in the applicable classes need only meet the time-in-class requirements and demonstrate that their performance has been satisfactory. IMS: from class FS-5 to FS-4 following completion of 18 months in class with satisfactory performance.
At the time a member becomes eligible for a scheduled administrative promotion, the Director General may order the deferral or denial of a promotion if the Director General determines such promotion would be inconsistent with the national interest or the efficiency of the Service. Such determinations must be based upon the procedures published in 3 FAH-1 H-2320.So what are these in-depth procedures to make sure my promotion isn't inconsistent with the national interest or the efficiency of the Service?
It's a lot of words to say they ask our bosses if we're satisfactory. I love government policies. :-) After this it does get complicated as competitive promotions are decided by promotion boards judging us based on our our employee evaluations. There's many more pages of policy which try to make that subjective judgement into a fair and repeatable process.a. At least one month before completion of the time-in-class required for an administrative promotion, the Director of the Office of Performance Evaluation in the Bureau of Human Resources (HR/PE) will inform the respective post or bureau of the member's eligibility for promotion and inquire whether the member's current performance has been judged satisfactory by the supervisor.b. The post or bureau will advise HR/PE whether the member's performance has been satisfactory or unsatisfactory.
So what do we get with our promotions? Private sector pay rates and raises are more private affairs. There's usually more flexibility and room for negotiation. In contrast, public sector promotions and pay raises are well known and rigid with a specific 6% formula:
Any member of the Foreign Service promoted to a higher class in the Foreign Service Schedule established under section 403 of the Act shall receive a base salary at the lowest step rate of the higher class which exceeds the existing rate of base salary by not less than two step increases or six percent, whichever is greater, of the class from which promoted.The foreign service pay chart is available for anyone to look at and that convoluted policy language tells us how we move up the chart by rounding up to the 6% higher step in the next grade. All of our salaries fit into these tidy charts instead of getting individualized amounts like a lot of the private sector.
For my new hire classmates still adjusting to public service life...
Welcome to the Machine!